Rank 5 to 10. I'll tally the results mid week.
|
|
Rank the best NFL RB's of all time
Rank 5 to 10. I'll tally the results mid week.
So skip 1 thru 4?
3 users like RockFlagandEagle's post: BraveSooner, party1234, Peach Fuzz
SighOriginally Posted by RockFlagandEagle
The following users like this post: RockFlagandEagle
1. Barry Sanders
2. Emmitt Smith
With longevity, AD will become #1.
1. Jim Brown
2. Barry Sanders
3. AD
4. Walter Payton
Brown
Sanders
Payton
Peterson
Emmitt
OJ
****erson
Franco Harris(got to put a Steeler on there).
Retired..
Jim Brown
OJ
Sanders
Payton
Sayers
Emmit
Dorsett
Franco
****erson
A ****ing D /thread
1. Sanders
2. Payton
3. Peterson
4. ****erson
5. Simpson
6. Brown
Smith is obviously a glaring ommission from the list. I don't believe he could have put up the numbers on the teams these 6 guys played on.
I thought the same. Think he meant 5 or 10. ****ing Romo!
1. All Day
2. Greg Pruitt
3. Billy Sims
4. Joe Washington
5. Demarco
5.
8 users like BraveSooner's post: ab5sr, ArmySooner, boleybuster, land burglar73507, Sooner94, soonerprices, TenYards, Yungpoisna
1. Barrysanders
2. Jim brown
3. Walter Payton
4. ****erson
5. AD
Barry sanders
1. Brown
2. Peterson
3. Payton
1. Barry
2. OJ
3. Brown
4. ****erson
5. AD
Poppy****
1. Barry Sanders
2. Thurman Thomas
3. Terry Miller
4. Bob Fenimore
5. Adrian Peterson
The following users like this post: Tug Medick
Actually, I hate the Dallas Cowboys but that DeMarco Murray is a fun back to watch.
Yeah, OJs probably one. I mean 2k in 14 games is unmatched. The fact he did it with little around him is nuts. But you knew that.
One season doesnt a career make ... yeah
larry csonka
pete banaszak
jim kick
rocky blier
ed podolak
The following users like this post: ArmySooner
You mean little like Pro HOF Joe DeLamielleure and College HOF and perennial Pro Bowler Reggie McKenzie? You mean a little like The Electric Company, Jim Braxton, and Joe Ferguson? But you knew that.
The following users like this post: cccasooner2
I wasn't alive when guys like Jim Brown and Walter Payton played, but I'll give it a shot anyways.
1. Emmitt
2. Payton
3. Brown
4. Sanders
5. AD (Will be higher by the time his career ends)
6. OJ
7. ****erson
8. Sayers
9. Dorsett
10. LT
Are we playing a game of 'Jump to Conclusions'?
Greatness does have to be interpreted to include longevity.
Barry Sanders
Jim Brown
Walter Payton
Gale Sayers
Emmitt Smith
Eric ****erson
Earl Campbell
AD
Tony Dorsett
Bo Jackson
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
This will be fun (and easy) when AD retires.
I can't rank AD up that high yet. He still needs to do this for a few more years to get up there in my book but he's a hall of famer if he has played his last game right now. That's how good he is.
Hell yes with the Ed Podolak reference. Serious old school.larry csonka
pete banaszak
jim kick
rocky blier
ed podolak
Will Payton make your top 10 list? Top 15? The suspense is killing me.
Who is Will Payton?
He was a punter for the L A Raiders.
Sanders
****erson
Smith
Brown
Payton
Sayers
Riggins
Podolak
Kelly
Harris
Thomas
Garrison
Muncy
Peterson*
*-for now
All so good they made one playoff? I'm familiar with all of these players. You throwing our ferguson is like someone saying romo is a great qb.
Ok, I was drunk last night. My list was terrible. I had AD in the top 5 and no sweetness? But ferguson?
Sanders
Jim Brown
OJ
****erson
Sweetness
Campbell
Emmit
Dorsett
Tomlinson
Sayers would be up there but he only played a limited number of years..Too early for me to put AD into the top ten but he will rocket to the top if he performs for another couple of years...
Last edited by pphilfran; 12-31-2012 at 12:23 PM.
Nothing wrong with this list.
Last edited by Tug Medick; 12-31-2012 at 12:26 PM.
The following users like this post: pphilfran
Sanders
Brown
****erson
AD
Payton
Cambell
Smith
1. ..Sanders. No question.
2. AD
3. Brown
4. Payton
5. ****erson
6. Sims
7. cambell
8. Emmit Smith
9. Pruitt
10.OJ
Sanders
Peterson
****erson
Payton
Simpson
I think some of us are on different wavelengths. Some are taking the entire career into account and some are going off the eye test. I am going off the eye test and saying top 3 right now that has ever played the game. Career? Already top 10, IMO.
I think you've made an oversight. Dorsett listed twice; Payton absent.
Damn...Sweetness ahead of Dorsett...
I wouldn't have a problem moving AD to #4 and Emmitt down a spot.
1. Barry Sanders
2. Jim Brown
3. Walter Payton
4. Emmitt Smith
5. Adrian Peterson
6. Eric ****erson
7. Tony Dorsett
7. Earl Campbell
8. OJ Simpson
9. Thurman Thomas
10. LaDainian Tomlinson
See these Jim Brown highlights. Awesome for sure. The guy seemed to be almost impossible to take down. However, he doesn't have the breakaway speed that AD
(Bo Jackson) has. Nor does he have the moves of Sanders or Payton. I never saw Jim play. I've just always heard that he's without a doubt the best ever. I cannot come to that conclusion just from watching these highlights.
Can you?
Now watch AD. They left out that bad**** run where he basically jumped and kicked that dude in the face and literally ran over him.
I'd have to say that AD is certainly faster than Jim and it looks like he punishes people more, much more. Jim seemed to be unbelievable at staying on his feet.
This doesn't take into account that the players these two go up against are from completely different eras. Today's NFL athlete is a much different creature than they were 50 years ago. That fact cannot be denied.
Personally, I think Jim gets the automatic #1 vote simply because that has always been everyone's answer. It's a paradigm.
Christian Okoye
Ki-Jana Carter
Ron Dayne
Archie Griffin
Ickey Woods
You left off Curt Warner.
If Bo had had a longer career there is a really good chance he'd have been a top 5 back
ADs not done yet. Let it play out.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
you must be a Bengals fan
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote
