do Christians/Muslims worship the same god?

Posted 651 day(s) ago by 87sooner4722 Views 191 Replies
Results 151 to 192 of 192
Page 4 of 4 2 3 4
  1. #151
    Aurora's Avatar
    Posts
    31,553
    Join Date
    May 2011
    Location
    The Dark Side

    Originally Posted by soonerbornsoonerbret View Post
    You get tired of fightingabout dog food too?
    yes I was trying not piss off nole by taking my dog to the vet instead of reading on the internet about how to care for her =)
    The following users like this post: soonerbornsoonerbrett


  2. #152
    Aurora's Avatar
    Posts
    31,553
    Join Date
    May 2011
    Location
    The Dark Side

    Originally Posted by 87sooner View Post
    stick to your new years resolution....
    you missed me

  3. #153
    Originally Posted by Aurora View Post
    yes I was trying not piss off nole by taking my dog to the vet instead of reading on the internet about how to care for her =)
    Gettin pretty bad when we have to come hide in Thunderdome!

  4. #154
    Morningwood's Avatar
    Posts
    2,760
    Join Date
    Nov 2011

    Originally Posted by 87sooner View Post
    a. i did refer to the bible.....john 1:1....extremely clear......

    b. see a
    You seriously want to go back to this?

    1:1 and 1:18 to support your stance, they're unclear at best. 'Extremely clear', that's pretty funny dude. "In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God" ..... "Nobody's seen God, Except his Son Jesus, who is God". Yep, clear as a bell!

    Here's what Jesus actually said:

    John 14:28 - My Father is greater than I. (hmm)
    John 20:17 - I ascend unto my Father, and your Father; and to my God, and your God. (I ascend to.. myself? No.)
    Matthew 19:17 - And he said unto him, Why callest thou me good? there is none good but one, that is, God.
    Matthew 27:46 - My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me? (was Jesus schizophrenic??)

    Here's what Jesus's disciples said:
    1 Peter 3:21-22 - Jesus Christ; who is on the the right hand of God. (Peter, obviously)
    Colossians 3:1 - Christ sitteth on the right hand of God. (Paul)
    Mark 16:19 - So then after the Lord had spoken unto them, he was received up into heaven, and sat on the right hand of God. (Mark)

    This shit is clear. John 1 is a tough sell, trying to prove your point.

    How can you call yourself a Christian, then insinuate Jesus and all his disciples are liars?

  5. #155
    Aurora's Avatar
    Posts
    31,553
    Join Date
    May 2011
    Location
    The Dark Side

    Originally Posted by soonerbornsoonerbret View Post
    Gettin pretty bad when we have to come hide in Thunderdome!
    This thread is actually a pretty funny read ... especially for a girl who doesn't believe in god

  6. #156
    Originally Posted by Morningwood View Post
    You seriously want to go back to this?

    1:1 and 1:18 to support your stance, they're unclear at best. 'Extremely clear', that's pretty funny dude. "In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God" ..... "Nobody's seen God, Except his Son Jesus, who is God". Yep, clear as a bell!

    Here's what Jesus actually said:

    John 14:28 - My Father is greater than I. (hmm)
    John 20:17 - I ascend unto my Father, and your Father; and to my God, and your God. (I ascend to.. myself? No.)
    Matthew 19:17 - And he said unto him, Why callest thou me good? there is none good but one, that is, God.
    Matthew 27:46 - My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me? (was Jesus schizophrenic??)

    Here's what Jesus's disciples said:
    1 Peter 3:21-22 - Jesus Christ; who is on the the right hand of God. (Peter, obviously)
    Colossians 3:1 - Christ sitteth on the right hand of God. (Paul)
    Mark 16:19 - So then after the Lord had spoken unto them, he was received up into heaven, and sat on the right hand of God. (Mark)

    This shit is clear. John 1 is a tough sell, trying to prove your point.

    How can you call yourself a Christian, then insinuate Jesus and all his disciples are liars?
    yes....i will always start and finish with john 1:1.....it is crystal clear....
    and in between i'll throw in john 10: 30 I and the Father are one.

    or how bout john 8: 58 “Very truly I tell you,” Jesus answered, “before Abraham was born, I am!”

    john 10: 33 “We are not stoning you for any good work,” they replied, “but for blasphemy, because you, a mere man, claim to be God.”

    Jesus was crucified because He claimed to be God....

    i am not insinuating that Jesus and His disciples were liars....
    i am saying you are confused/misinformed

    and if you believe Jesus was not God......and you call yourself christian.....you are once again....confused or misinformed....

  7. #157
    Dexa's Avatar
    Posts
    3,231
    Join Date
    Sep 2011
    Location
    Moore

    This is an awesome debate. It is truly entertaining to me. This is also why I never have scripture debate.

  8. #158
    Originally Posted by Morningwood View Post
    Hell no but I think they are probably among the best students of the Bible, as a group. Their problem is how they take liberties with "what should be read literally" and what shouldn't. And the fact they crystallized some beliefs *before* they made their own translation, then poof - their beliefs perfectly align with the Bible.
    That's true of anyone especially our friend 87. He claims he takes the bible literally but as we've seen here, he is clearly putting a spin (interpretation) on John 1:1.
    The following users like this post: Morningwood


  9. #159
    Morningwood's Avatar
    Posts
    2,760
    Join Date
    Nov 2011

    Originally Posted by 87sooner View Post
    yes....i will always start and finish with john 1:1.....it is crystal clear....
    and in between i'll throw in john 10: 30 I and the Father are one.

    or how bout john 8: 58 “Very truly I tell you,” Jesus answered, “before Abraham was born, I am!”

    john 10: 33 “We are not stoning you for any good work,” they replied, “but for blasphemy, because you, a mere man, claim to be God.”

    Jesus was crucified because He claimed to be God....

    i am not insinuating that Jesus and His disciples were liars....
    i am saying you are confused/misinformed

    and if you believe Jesus was not God......and you call yourself christian.....you are once again....confused or misinformed....
    I am not a church-going, company-line "Christian". Just an avid studier and observer of religion.

    Regarding John 8:58 - Of course Jesus existed before Abraham. ACCORDING TO THE BIBLE, Jesus was there from almost the very beginning of time.

    John 10:3 - "The guys who crucified Jesus said he claimed he was God"?? Dude, you're making the same insinuation Jesus's killers made.

    It's very simple. JESUS HIMSELF said he was the Son of God. Jesus didn't profess he was God. He was very clear about this. NONE of his disciples thought he was God. They all understood he was the Son of God. Offspring, not one and the same. There is no denying this, or fiddling with the verbage to fit your version.

    I posted seven or eight verses that most would think are very clear, and I have about 4 dozen more. You posted two verses that require a squint of the eyes and a tilt of the head to faintly understand how someone could misconstrue it as you have.

    What do you make of all the scripture clearly stating otherwise? Straight from Jesus's mouth?? It's just.... rubbish?

    John 6:38-40 -
    For I have come down from heaven, not to do my own will, but the will of him who sent me; and this is the will of him who sent me, that I should lose nothing of all that he has given me, but raise it up at the last day. For this is the will of my Father, that every one who sees the Son and believes in him should have eternal life; and I will raise him up at the last day.

    So either Jesus was a schizophrenic god and compulsive liar, or you've got it wrong. Seriously, read the Bible on your own. If you believe the Bible is the word of God, read it on your own and you'll soon understand how organized religion is very likely organized by Satan. You're all caught up in it bro.

  10. #160
    Morningwood's Avatar
    Posts
    2,760
    Join Date
    Nov 2011

    Originally Posted by brokebacksooner View Post
    That's true of anyone especially our friend 87. He claims he takes the bible literally but as we've seen here, he is clearly putting a spin (interpretation) on John 1:1.
    No doubt some more than others but yes, all the organizations do it.

    The funny thing is how the original word has survived, mostly intact, for millenia. Despite man's inclination to twist it up.
    The following users like this post: Dexa


  11. #161
    Originally Posted by brokebacksooner View Post
    That's true of anyone especially our friend 87. He claims he takes the bible literally but as we've seen here, he is clearly putting a spin (interpretation) on John 1:1.
    now don't start spreading lies brokeback..
    and go right ahead and explain how i've "spun" john 1:1...

  12. #162
    Originally Posted by Morningwood View Post
    I am not a church-going, company-line "Christian". Just an avid studier and observer of religion.

    Regarding John 8:58 - Of course Jesus existed before Abraham. ACCORDING TO THE BIBLE, Jesus was there from almost the very beginning of time.

    John 10:3 - "The guys who crucified Jesus said he claimed he was God"?? Dude, you're making the same insinuation Jesus's killers made.

    It's very simple. JESUS HIMSELF said he was the Son of God. Jesus didn't profess he was God. He was very clear about this. NONE of his disciples thought he was God. They all understood he was the Son of God. Offspring, not one and the same. There is no denying this, or fiddling with the verbage to fit your version.

    I posted seven or eight verses that most would think are very clear, and I have about 4 dozen more. You posted two verses that require a squint of the eyes and a tilt of the head to faintly understand how someone could misconstrue it as you have.

    What do you make of all the scripture clearly stating otherwise? Straight from Jesus's mouth?? It's just.... rubbish?

    John 6:38-40 -
    For I have come down from heaven, not to do my own will, but the will of him who sent me; and this is the will of him who sent me, that I should lose nothing of all that he has given me, but raise it up at the last day. For this is the will of my Father, that every one who sees the Son and believes in him should have eternal life; and I will raise him up at the last day.

    So either Jesus was a schizophrenic god and compulsive liar, or you've got it wrong. Seriously, read the Bible on your own. If you believe the Bible is the word of God, read it on your own and you'll soon understand how organized religion is very likely organized by Satan. You're all caught up in it bro.

    you can't seem to comprehend that i have not insinuated Jesus and His disciples are liars.........YOU are the liar....
    you are a jehovah's witness.....you've bought into the lie....no big deal.....many people do....
    post all 4 dozen verses if you want....you are taking them all out of context.....you are an "observer of religion"....but you know nothing about the scripture you quote...
    but there are people here like teo and preterist who are far smarter than i.....trying to tell you you are wrong......but you and brokeback act like i'm the only one who believes Jesus is God....

  13. #163
    Coach's Avatar
    Posts
    10,995
    Join Date
    Apr 2012

    do Christians/Muslims worship the same god?

    Has morningwood been banned under another user name?

  14. #164
    McRib's Avatar
    Posts
    25,199
    Join Date
    Oct 2011

    do Christians/Muslims worship the same god?

    Originally Posted by soonerprices View Post
    Has morningwood been banned under another user name?
    No.

  15. #165
    Originally Posted by Morningwood View Post
    Considered heretical... by whom?

    And when you say (orthodox) Christians, do you mean Orthodox Christians? Or just (orthodox) Christians. I ask because (orthodox) Christians could mean anyone who bases their beliefs on what the Bible says. "Orthodox Christians" is the Eastern Orthodox Church. Not exactly the same thing.
    I don't mean Eastern Orthodox. I mean those sects that ascribe to orthodox Christian belief (that tends to include Eastern Orthodox). There are not many beliefs that are necessary to fall under that blanket, but Christ being God is unequivocally one of them. To deny such a thing is heresy (which by definition substantiates orthodoxy).

    I'm not saying heretical is "wrong"...I'm saying it's not orthodox, which is to say it's an outlier amongst the most rational and *useful* definition of Christian.
    The following users like this post: Morningwood


  16. #166
    Sooner Bob's Avatar
    Posts
    6,076
    Join Date
    Sep 2012
    Location
    North of Waterloo Road

    Is the sticking point here trying to determine what the "Son of God" actually means? Because I'm seeing 87 posting that it implies Christ and God being equal and Morningwood implying that it means they're separate.

  17. #167
    Originally Posted by Sooner Bob View Post
    Is the sticking point here trying to determine what the "Son of God" actually means? Because I'm seeing 87 posting that it implies Christ and God being equal and Morningwood implying that it means they're separate.
    the sticking point is mw denies Jesus is God......which puts him at odds with one of the main tenets of christianity....

  18. #168
    Sooner Bob's Avatar
    Posts
    6,076
    Join Date
    Sep 2012
    Location
    North of Waterloo Road

    Originally Posted by 87sooner View Post
    the sticking point is mw denies Jesus is God......which puts him at odds with one of the main tenets of christianity....
    If they were separate I really think John would've cleared that up when he wrote it . . . afterall, his gospel is supposed to be about who Jesus really is right?

  19. #169
    Morningwood's Avatar
    Posts
    2,760
    Join Date
    Nov 2011

    If... IF it was John's job to clear that up, I'd say he horribly failed. Honestly. But I don't have to fight any preconceived notions that were drilled into my head by my parents or a church.

    The only proof you have, Sooner87, and this is giving you very strong benefit of the doubt - is a cryptic message hidden inside a riddle, and a verse unlike almost all other Bible translations in history, retrofitted by people desperate for biblical support of their belief. And then you googled for a few more that are so far off it's simply a waste of time.

    Does it not raise a red flag, in your mind? Jesus himself, the gospels, et al. straight-up saying God is the father of Jesus? No hidden meanings or encoded messages, always very direct, contextual or otherwise? Does that not put you at odds?

    If you could prove the context totally turns around Jesus's words, you would. But you can't do it. Listen dude, you don't need a smart guy to translate what things mean. The bible was intended to be readable and digestable by anyone. I politely recommend you stop listening to some mealy-mouth career church zombie telling you what to believe, read the bible for yourself and make your own opinion.

  20. #170
    Morningwood's Avatar
    Posts
    2,760
    Join Date
    Nov 2011

    And to be clear: this is not a hot topic for me, I really don't care what you believe. I respect your view but your personality begs to be ****ed with. Plus I like the easy side of arguments and you're a willing antagonist
    The following users like this post: brokebacksooner


  21. #171
    Originally Posted by Morningwood View Post
    If... IF it was John's job to clear that up, I'd say he horribly failed. Honestly. But I don't have to fight any preconceived notions that were drilled into my head by my parents or a church.

    The only proof you have, Sooner87, and this is giving you very strong benefit of the doubt - is a cryptic message hidden inside a riddle, and a verse unlike almost all other Bible translations in history, retrofitted by people desperate for biblical support of their belief. And then you googled for a few more that are so far off it's simply a waste of time.

    Does it not raise a red flag, in your mind? Jesus himself, the gospels, et al. straight-up saying God is the father of Jesus? No hidden meanings or encoded messages, always very direct, contextual or otherwise? Does that not put you at odds?

    If you could prove the context totally turns around Jesus's words, you would. But you can't do it. Listen dude, you don't need a smart guy to translate what things mean. The bible was intended to be readable and digestable by anyone. I politely recommend you stop listening to some mealy-mouth career church zombie telling you what to believe, read the bible for yourself and make your own opinion.
    God is the father of Jesus the man....not Jesus the God

  22. #172
    btw...this parallels our discussion wrt God/allah.....

    if you compare the nature/characteristics of Jesus/God....you must conclude they are the same
    if you compare the nature/characteristics of God/allah....you must conclude they are vastly different

  23. #173
    Yuck Fu's Avatar
    Posts
    5,038
    Join Date
    Mar 2011
    Location
    Ah so, mutha fucka.

    Originally Posted by 87sooner View Post
    btw...this parallels our discussion wrt God/allah.....

    if you compare the nature/characteristics of Jesus/God....you must conclude they are the same
    if you compare the nature/characteristics of God/allah....you must conclude they are vastly different
    Nobody "must" conclude either of the above.

    Jesus was half human when he was on earth. So not exactly the same as God at least during his earthly period.

    Allah/God was the same diety at least until Isaac and Ishmael. It ican be reasoned that Allah/God are the same diety now but (at least according to Christians/Jews) Muslims are so far off track that God won't accept their worship of Allah..

    God (according to Christianity) feels that the Jews got off track when they rejected Jesus. The Muslims got off track earlier and (according to the Jews and later Christians) and got so far off track that they refer to a false prophet and follow an unholy scripture set.

    Allah could be considered a perverted (again according to Christians and Jews) definition of the JudeoChristian God.
    The following users like this post: Morningwood


  24. #174
    Originally Posted by Yuck Fu View Post
    Nobody "must" conclude either of the above.

    Jesus was half human when he was on earth. So not exactly the same as God at least during his earthly period.

    Allah/God was the same diety at least until Isaac and Ishmael. It ican be reasoned that Allah/God are the same diety now but (at least according to Christians/Jews) Muslims are so far off track that God won't accept their worship of Allah..

    God (according to Christianity) feels that the Jews got off track when they rejected Jesus. The Muslims got off track earlier and (according to the Jews and later Christians) and got so far off track that they refer to a false prophet and follow an unholy scripture set.

    Allah could be considered a perverted (again according to Christians and Jews) definition of the JudeoChristian God.
    Jesus was ALL human and All God at the same time....i've never heard anyone say He was "half human"....

    allah didn't exist prior to ishmael.........
    we are the creation of God.....allah is the creation of man...

  25. #175
    Dexa's Avatar
    Posts
    3,231
    Join Date
    Sep 2011
    Location
    Moore

    Originally Posted by 87sooner View Post
    Jesus was ALL human and All God at the same time....i've never heard anyone say He was "half human"....

    allah didn't exist prior to ishmael.........
    we are the creation of God.....allah is the creation of man...
    I suppose that depends on which language developed first. I'll give you two guesses.

  26. #176
    Originally Posted by Dexa View Post
    I suppose that depends on which language developed first. I'll give you two guesses.
    what depends on language? not following you....

  27. #177
    Dexa's Avatar
    Posts
    3,231
    Join Date
    Sep 2011
    Location
    Moore

    Originally Posted by 87sooner View Post
    what depends on language? not following you....
    If "God" or "Allah" was before the other. I mean.. the Aramaic name for God is Eleh.. right?

  28. #178
    Yuck Fu's Avatar
    Posts
    5,038
    Join Date
    Mar 2011
    Location
    Ah so, mutha fucka.

    Originally Posted by 87sooner View Post
    Jesus was ALL human and All God at the same time....i've never heard anyone say He was "half human"....

    allah didn't exist prior to ishmael.........
    we are the creation of God.....allah is the creation of man...
    Genetically Jesus was half human and half God. But I won't belabor that point.

    However, Since Muslims believe in the creation story, the flood story, and everything up to Abraham and Isaac then who was the God that did all that? God/Allah did. Same diety.

    In reality however, the Isaac, Ishmael, Sarah, Hagar story is one that tries to describe the genesis of two seperate cultures among the semites of that early period. During this time, the perceptions of "God" between the two cultures began to become disimilar culminating in the bible and the Koran.

    You can see it differently but I just can't considering Allah is the generic word for God and that the Abrahamic faiths have a shared beginning. The Muslims certainly don't think that Allah only existed after Ishmael.
    The following users like this post: Coach


  29. #179
    Sooner Bob's Avatar
    Posts
    6,076
    Join Date
    Sep 2012
    Location
    North of Waterloo Road

    Isn't a trinity made up of three things? Three equal things?

  30. #180

    do Christians/Muslims worship the same god?

    Originally Posted by heff View Post
    C'mon. This is obvious even to people with a tertiary knowledge of the Bible.
    The thread went off the rails before I got back to that.

  31. #181
    Originally Posted by heff View Post
    C'mon. This is obvious even to people with a tertiary knowledge of the Bible.
    well....since cub hasn't responded.....how so?

  32. #182

    do Christians/Muslims worship the same god?

    Originally Posted by 87sooner View Post
    well....since cub hasn't responded.....how so?
    He was regularly wiping people out and had an overtly active hand in the OT. Much more wrathful. It's like he invented Prozac in the NT.

  33. #183

    do Christians/Muslims worship the same god?

    S&G, Noah, raining hell on the Egyptians, the lion's den, Shadrach, Meshach and Abednego, blowing trumpets knocking down walls, killing everyone and salting earth, vengeance is mine, Solomon, David and Goliath-- OT God. NT God--love your neighbor.
    2 users like oucub23's post: brokebacksooner, Morningwood


  34. #184
    Sooner Bob's Avatar
    Posts
    6,076
    Join Date
    Sep 2012
    Location
    North of Waterloo Road

    His covenant with man was different . . . and then the Jews greatly expounded on the laws. That's probably as big of a change between testaments IMO.

  35. #185
    Morningwood's Avatar
    Posts
    2,760
    Join Date
    Nov 2011

    Originally Posted by Sooner Bob View Post
    Isn't a trinity made up of three things? Three equal things?
    Yeah and this issue looks like a big deal on the surface, but it's really just trivial. I appreciate your respectful interjections and you had the best verse to support your argument. This part of the belief in a higher power is really semantics and unimportant. I think so anyway.

    The Allah/God debate is much more interesting

  36. #186
    VUGear's Avatar
    Posts
    1,607
    Join Date
    Nov 2011

    Originally Posted by Sooner Bob View Post
    Isn't a trinity made up of three things? Three equal things?
    On that note, we could use a thread on the whole infralapsarianism versus supralapsarianism thing...

  37. #187
    SpankyNek's Avatar
    Posts
    12,392
    Join Date
    Oct 2010
    Location
    Houston (Cypress)

    Originally Posted by VUGear View Post
    On that note, we could use a thread on the whole infralapsarianism versus supralapsarianism thing...
    I would love such a discussion...we have a few folks on here that could probably enlighten the both of us.

  38. #188
    Originally Posted by 87sooner View Post
    now don't start spreading lies brokeback..
    and go right ahead and explain how i've "spun" john 1:1...
    I think MW covered it better than I can and before you start getting all jealous again; no he's not my boyfriend.

  39. #189
    Originally Posted by brokebacksooner View Post
    I think MW covered it better than I can and before you start getting all jealous again; no he's not my boyfriend.
    i didn't realize you were a jw too....
    do they also sanction gay marriage?

  40. #190
    surus's Avatar
    Posts
    604
    Join Date
    Jan 2011
    Location
    Vietnam, HCMC

    Originally Posted by Yuck Fu View Post
    Genetically Jesus was half human and half God. But I won't belabor that point.

    However, Since Muslims believe in the creation story, the flood story, and everything up to Abraham and Isaac then who was the God that did all that? God/Allah did. Same diety.

    In reality however, the Isaac, Ishmael, Sarah, Hagar story is one that tries to describe the genesis of two seperate cultures among the semites of that early period. During this time, the perceptions of "God" between the two cultures began to become disimilar culminating in the bible and the Koran.

    You can see it differently but I just can't considering Allah is the generic word for God and that the Abrahamic faiths have a shared beginning. The Muslims certainly don't think that Allah only existed after Ishmael.
    they both believe in the WHAT, but not the WHO

  41. #191
    Originally Posted by 87sooner View Post
    God is the father of Jesus the man....not Jesus the God
    You might be careful there. Orthodoxy generally holds that the Father/Son relationship is eternal. It's a fine point that tends to be grasping at straws exegetically, but most scholars would probably take issue with your description.

  42. #192
    Alright, to put this another way, so that you all understand a very important thing about religious talks.

    Words are approximate descriptors of all things, but particularly metaphysical things. The term Allah literally translates as "(the) God". And God, would literally translate as "Allah".

    In reality that makes the terms pretty useless, as you can say that anyone who believes in God believes in Allah.

    The word Allah is only as useful as the weight it carries in regards to what it represents. Carrying the full weight of what it represents, Allah can only be understood in the light of Islam, and even within Islam that term has a variety of meanings. To assert that Allah is the same God as Yahweh or the "Theos" of the New Testament is to issue a different weight by which Allah is understood. In argument this is known as "equivocation". It's not allowed.

    The same can be said of saying that the Christian God is the same as Allah.

    Now, to be sure, at some point in history there was a time where the ancestors of the Muslims and the ancestors of the Jews (and by extension, "Christians") were in the same family and they likely used the same term to approximately describe the same being (as much as any group of people can use a word with a common understanding). The words used today to describe each sect's particular deity stemmed from that same word, but the meanings became greatly varied and by any measure of "reality", those words approximately describe very different beings.

Similar Threads

  1. Please. Enough Of The MJ Worship
    By KCRuf/Nek in forum Wayman's House
    Replies: 35
    Last Post: March 24th, 2013, 02:44 PM
  2. do baptists/Catholics worship the same god?
    By OnlyOneOklahoma in forum ThunderDome
    Replies: 27
    Last Post: January 22nd, 2013, 02:06 PM
  3. American Muslims Want Limits on Free Speech
    By kssooner in forum ThunderDome
    Replies: 92
    Last Post: October 2nd, 2012, 12:36 PM